Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Comment #2 --

How do you feel about surgery? As it stands this piece strikes me as two separate ones: The first all background and summary, the second is an actual scene. I'm proposing a way to integrate them.

First off, we're looking at a man (Andrew) who wants to find love. He's somewhat nurturing -- the plants -- but rather hands-off because he relies on technology to search for another person. He has enormous authority around the "Post" material, yet his coldness still comes through because he never ponders the dead as people who were beloved and who lived lives. Here your horse of "coldness" emerges. I'd like to see you hit that horse/theme as many ways as possible. He likes his food cold: gazpacho, chilled wine, etc..

Now the surgery... How about opening with the date (Jamie) asking, "What was your favorite 'post'?" She cringes and rephrases (so we get a beat of her appearance and physicality) restating her question, "Maybe your most interesting..."

At that our guy launches into a jargon-heavy account of dissecting an older man... This account is intercut with his personal history, his career path, his family. And gradually the reader realizes (you must not make this connection overt, let the reader grasp it) that the autopsy is him alone cutting up his own dead father. Examining the brain, the heart, the lungs. The genitals.

Perhaps with subtle physical tells, the date also realizes the man is describing butchering his own father in search of... something. Love? A soul? Humanity?

This intercutting would allow you to unpack the man's search for love, and it would integrate the two dissimilar halves of the story. Again, this is just a suggestion to break the ice. You could still use the current ending; in fact, you could use most of what you already have on the page.

So far your "horses" would be 'cold' and 'the search for love.' In sorting through his father's innards, he'd also be recognizing aspects of himself, including the facial features. All these elements are already present in the story -- good job! -- so all you'd need do is rearrange a bit.

Karin Kohlmeier's avatar

Hi Matt,

Great story! I'm going to try to drop in later with more thoughts, but one thing stuck out to me immediately -- the part where Jamie says, "I have to pee. Get me a beer" then goes off to the bathroom. There is absolutely no way a savvy character like her is going to leave a man she's never met alone with her drink.

Ok, one more thing. "Dark passenger" is very specific to Dexter. Is there another phrase she can use that's unique to her? (For what it's worth, I did get that she's a killer, and I would love to see more about how she would navigate actually having feelings for a man she had intended to murder. There's so much potential in that!)

120 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?